| Post-Remediation
Verification (PRV) of Mold / Bacteria Remediation Projects - Risk-Based
Levels of Cleanliness Assurance- 2nd Edition
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1. WHAT IS POST-REMEDIATION
VERIFICATION (PRV)?
___A.
Where Did the Concept of Clearance Testing Come From?
___B. Similarities
to Asbestos Abatement
___C. Dissimilarities
Between Lead Abatement and Mold Remediation
___D. How Mold / Bacteria
Remediation PRV Differs from Asbestos and Lead Clearance Testing
___E. Why Do PRV for
Mold Remediation Jobs?
CHAPTER 2. POST-REMEDIATION VERIFICATION STANDARDS FOR MOLD
& BACTERIA
__Trade
Associations
___A.
Institute for Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification
(IICRC) S500 (1991)
___B. Institute for
Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification (IICRC) S520
(2004)
___C. American Industrial
Hygiene Association (AIHA) 2004 Document
___D. American Conference
of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) 1999 Document
___E. National Air
Duct Cleaners Association (NADCA) ACR 2005
___F. International
Society of Indoor Air Quality Guidelines (ISIAQ) (1996)
_Governmental Bodies
___G.
Federal Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) 2001 Guidlines
___H. New York City
Department of Health (NYCDOH) 1994/2002 Document
___I. Texas Department
of Health (TDH) 2004 Regulation
CHAPTER 3. SUMMARY OF VARIOUS PRV STANDARDS
___A.
Requirements for PRV
___B. Visual Inspection
___C. Air Sampling
and/or Surface Sampling
___D. Correction of
the Water Source
___E. Inspection of
the Work-In-Progress
___F. Mold Odor Abatement
___G. Moisture Level
Control
___H. The Use of Biocides
___I. Re-inspection
After Restoration is Complete
___J. Considerations
Given to High-Risk Occupant Populations
___K. Summary of Recommended
Post-Remediation Verification Criteria
CHAPTER 4. OBJECTIVES OF MOLD / BACTERIA PRV
___A.
Documentation of the Completion of a Small-Scale Microbial Remediation
Project
___B. Documentation
of Airborne Mold Spore Levels Being Normal
___C. Documentation
of Removal of Mold Contamination on Surfaces
___D. Documentation
of Bacteria Disinfection and Removal
___E. Documentation
of Health-Based Remediation Acceptability
______1.
Symptomatic Occupants
______2. Infection
Risk Occupants
CHAPTER 5. POST-REMEDIATION VERIFICATION LEVELS
___A.
PRV Level 0-A—Visual Inspection
___B. PRV Level 0-B—Visual
Inspection with Documentation
___C. PRV Level 1—Clearance
of Mold Remediation Projects for "Typical" Conditions
___D. PRV Level 2—Clearance
of Mold Remediation Projects for Persons Reporting Generalized Symptoms
___E. PRV Level 3—Clearance
of Mold Remediation Projects for Highly Sensitive Individuals
___F. PRV Level 4—Clearance
of Mold Remediation Projects in a Hospital
CHAPTER 6. POST-REMEDIATION VERIFICATION DOCUMENTATION PROTOCOLS
___A.
Begin at the Beginning (If Possible)—Contractual Definition
of Clearance
___B. Pre-Remediation
Inspection
______1. Identification
of the Source of Water / Moisture
______2. Pre-Remediation
Air Testing
______3. What About
Getting Involved in a Project Half-way Through?
___C. Development
of a Scope of Work
______1. Filtered
Dedicated Make-up Air
___D. Moisture Testing—Removal
of Water / Moisture
___E. Correction of
the Water / Moisture Source?
___F. Inspection /
Documentation During Remediation
___G. Visual Inspection
______1. Definitions
of Visibly Clean in Existing Standards
______2. Visual Inspection
Condition Comparison—Clean Room Versus Mold Remediation
______3. Eye Sight
Testing
___H. Analytical Clearance
Testing
______1. Conditions
During Clearance Testing
________a. Sample
at Least 7 Days After the Start of a Major Water Intrustion
________b. Optimum
Time of Day for Sampling
________c. Should
Dehumidifiers Be Off During Clearance Testing?
________d. Should
A Dehumidification Units Be On or Off During PRV and Analytical
Clearance Air Testing?
________e. Should
HEPA Air Scrubbers Be On or Off During Analytical Clearance Air
Testing?
______2. Aggressive
Air Sampling
________a. Varying
Levels of Cleanliness Assurance
________b. Potential
Sampling Bias
________c. Potential
Sampling Complications
________d. Cautions
for High-Risk Environments
________e. Not Applicable
to New Housing Construction?
________f. What Evaluation
Standard to Use
______3. Passive Air
Sampling
________a. The Need
for 24 Hours of Air Infiltration
________b. Properly
Shutting Off the NAMs
________c. Reestablishment
of Normal Building Air Flow and Pressure Differentials
__I. Air Testing—Viable
and Total Spore Sampling
______1. Percent Viability
(Culturable) Comparisons
______2. Comparing
Total Mold Spore Genera is Scientifically Inaccurate
________a. Polymerase
Chain Reaction (PCR) Sampling and Analysis
________3. Increased
Statistical Significance
__J. Surface Testing
______1. Tape Samples
______2. Swab Samples
________a. Fungal
Sampling
________b. Bacteria
Sample
__K. Mold Spore Analysis
of Surface Dust
__L. Surface Dust
Clearance Level Testing for Ductwork
__M. Bacteria Clearance
Level Testing
______1. Surface
______2. Air Testing
__N. Endotoxin Testing
__O. Fecal Steroids
CHAPTER 7. ANALYTICAL CLEARANCE TESTING—CLEANLINESS
STANDARDS
__A.
Air Clearance Testing Standards
______1. Comparative
and Rank Order Standards
______2. Clearance
Level Exposure Standards for Viable Mold Spores
________a. Normal
Levels of Mold Spores in Homes and Commercial Buildings
________b. Ceiling
Limits for Hospitals & Other Susceptible-Occupant Environments
______3. Level Exposure
Standards for Total Mold Spores
________a. Limitations
of Total Mold Spore Laboratory Analysis
______4. Clearance
Level Exposure Standards for Bacteria
______5. Clearance
Level Exposure Standards for Bacterial Endotoxins
______6. Federal Clean
Room Particulate Standards
__B. Surface Dust
Testing Standards for Ductwork
______1. NADCA
__C. Surface Dust
Fungal Spore Clearance Testing Standards
______1. mgc©—Occupational
Safety & Health Consulting
______2. Canada—Normal
Versus Contaminated Houses
______3. Germany
______4. OSHA
__D. Surface Bacteria
Standards
______1. European
Union Clean Room Standards
__E. Analytical Clearance
Testing Issues
______1. Effects of
Weather and Geographical Location
______2. Wintertime
Projects
______3. Sampling
a Room with Carpeting
______4. School Buildings
______5. Buildings
with Other Mold Contamination Problems
______6. Indoor Plants
______7. Pets
CHAPTER 8. THE STATISTICAL TECHNIQUES OF SMALL SET SAMPLING
__A.
Air Sampling Statistics
______1. Development
of Log-Normal, Small Sample Size, Confidence Level Statistics
________a. The Desired
Confidence Level
________b. The Normalized
Average of the Sampling Results
__________i. What
is Normalized Data?
__________ii. What
is the Normalized Average?
________c. The Geometric
Standard Deviation
__________i. The Log-Normalized
Average of the Sampling Results
__________ii. The
Standard Deviation of the Log-Normalized Average of the Sampling
Results
__________iii. The
Geometric Standard Deviation (GSD)
______2. Determining
the Minimum Number of Samples to Establish Statistical Significance
______3. The Establishment
of the "50% of Normal Mold Spore Levels" as a Clearance
Criteria
______4. Determining
Whether Clearance Air Monitoring Data is Statistically Significant
______5. Example Calculation
of Statistical Significance for Clearance Testing of Mold Spores
__B. Surface Sampling
Statistics
______1. Sampling
Tables for Various Acceptable Quality Levels (AQLs)
______2. Example Calculation
of Statistcial Significance for Surface Clearance Testing of Mold
Spores
__C. Should One Use
a Student's T-Test Statistic?
CHAPTER 9. WHO SHOULD BE PERFORMING PRV?
__A.
The Use of Qualified Individuals
__B. The Use of Qualified
Analysis Laboratories
__C. The Use of Calibrated
Equipment
__D. There Should
Be No Conflict of Interest Between the IEP and the Remediation Firm
__E. Should a Remediation
Contractor Do Their Own PRV Testing?
__F. Who Should Hire
the IEP?
__G. Should an IEP/Remediation
Contractor Analyze Their Own Samples?
LIST OF APPENDICES
APPENDIX 1: Selection
and Use of Biocides
APPENDIX 2: Selection
and Use of Mold-Retarding Encapsulants, Coatings, and Paints
APPENDIX 3: Sample
Post-Remediation Verification Level Checklists
APPENDIX 4: Sample
Infection Control Risk Assesment Procedures
APPENDIX 5: 95%
Confidence Level Analysis Graphs
APPENDIX 6: PRV
Selection Flowchart
BIBLIOGRAPHY
(over 140 references!) |